Jump to main content

Follow us on Twitter Twitter and Facebook Facebook!

Human Rights

Disability and Inclusive Education


By Gary Bunch

I am really interested in inclusive education and disability. I always have been, even when I was teaching in segregated education settings. I kept running into kids who could have been educated back home in their community schools. It seemed the only reason they were in special settings was that they qualified for some sort of label - and kids with educational labels went to special settings. Of course, back then integration for some students with disabilities was a new idea, even if it did carry with it the possibility that any student could be taken out of the regular class and put in a special setting if her/his achievement or performance changed.

Special education was a boon to kids with disabilities when it began to take off around the middle of the last century. Before that, kids with disabilities mostly were not in school. They stayed at home or were sent to institutions. The development and growth of special education meant that they could get an education, even though they had to go to segregated settings. At that time, special education also was a revolution - and a positive one.

But change does not stop happening. New and better ways to do things are found. That does not mean the older ways were bad. It just means that new ideas and new ways to do things have been found, and that they do a better job than do the older ideas and methods. Change is a constant, and it impacts education just as it does other aspects of society.

So, change is happening in education for learners with disabilities. We have learned that inclusion in the regular classrooms of community schools is better education than is inclusion. Though change to inclusion in education is not common everywhere, there are many teachers and parents who have chosen it. Teachers have found inclusion to work, and to work better than what was happening before. There is a learning curve, of course. Every change brings a learning curve with it.

Experience has shown that kids with disabilities are happier when they are educated with their regular peers. Teachers see this and parents see this. After a brief adjustment period, the regular peers accept their new schoolmates. The regular kids also benefit from having more diversity in their classrooms. They learn lessons that are not taught in the textbooks from which they study. They learn lessons of acceptance, support, and understanding.

The United Nations has recognized that being educated together in community schools is good for everyone. That is the base of the UN Education For All policy. The UN believes education together in regular community settings is the most effective way to combat discrimination based on some element of difference. Inclusion is a human right and is the practice of social justice.

That does not mean that everyone accepts that inclusive education is better. It is challenging to accept that what one has always understood is not the best answer anymore. Many governments cling to segregation for some students with disabilities because they cannot envision these students achieving more in regular settings - and, of course, they think change will be expensive. Many teachers cling to segregation because their professional development programs have not prepared them for change.

There are many reasons for resistance to change. And with resistance comes the heat and friction of impassioned discussion. Discussion is essential to moving forward in education for people with disabilities. I hope this blog will result in exchanges of views as we all move to a stronger, more positive future for learners with disabilities.

My next blog will talk about something that is happening in education im Mumbai, India. That "something" is happening in the huge slum of Dharavi, the slum where Slumdog Millionaire was filmed. Conditions in Dharavi are depressing in general. There is poverty everywhere. But there also is the most exciting program in education and disability I have seen anywhere.


Comments

Wow...this was a really good article. Probably one of the best I've read
Posted by: chrisawalik | Sunday June 14, 2009, 11:24 pm

IT is the first time I have visited this site and low and behold I come across this. I tip my hat to you as if we do open a door and let someone in how are we to know gifts they bring(as each one of us have). I myself have wounder what school staff does on PD days, I always thought they were being offered training. Not only would the general population of school learn acceptence and tolerance but so would or children and would also see that the world inside a school is bigger than in the one classroom they are in now
Posted by: lazybee | Thursday December 10, 2009, 10:53 am

There are very few, if any, special needs students in Fr. Immersion, at least in my Vancouver, B.C., experience. Nevertheless, few, if any, teachers until high school science have been able to ignite much of a flame even among truly motivated learners, those who are now in the International Baccalaureate (IB) Program, a sort of re-gentrification of public education, in my view, an effort return academic standards, altho not surprisingly, to access it requires the payment of what are actually illegal school fees.

I can't believe how few written assignments there have been throughout high school. Teachers here, at least, seem to favor oral presentations that may have little or nothing to do with the subject at hand. So many stupid skits modelled after TV sitcoms, so much coloring even in grade 11 and, of course, the requisite memorized speech EVERY SINGLE year! Easier to mark, no doubt.

In addition, there are so many long and repetitive assemblies devoted to the new green religion with little or no regard to actual science. At one point, we wondered if the teachers weren't hoping to exploit a captive market for their green sidelines.

I'm afraid at this point I have lost what respect I myself had for my own wonderful teachers.

I now look forward to the day when learning is done independently and kids have time to socialize with one another in authentic ways over some shared interest or other.

The model currently engaged is great for teachers and horrible for most kids!

Leo Biblitz

ASKBiblitz.com
Posted by: Leo Biblitz | Wednesday January 27, 2010, 4:58 pm



You must be logged in to add a comment. Log in
Promo graphic: Subscribe to Abilities
 
 
Important Survey on End of Life Services for People with Disabilities
The Canadian Abilities Foundation (CAF) is supporting Hospice Toronto in an initiative known as the Transitions Project. The objective is to help gain a greater understanding of the needs of people with disabilities as they deal with end of life issues. Hospice Toronto is inviting people with disabilities and those who care for them from across Canada to participate in the survey. Your point of view is needed and would be very much appreciated.

Hospice Toronto Transitions Project Survey
 
abilities.ca services
Directory of Disability Organizations in Canada - Browse or search the most comprehensive database of disability organizations in Canada
Access Guide Canada - Your guide to accessible places in Canada
Donate online - Help support the work of the Canadian Abilities Foundation
Subscribe - Order a subscription for yourself, and a gift subscription for a friend
Write for us - Read our writers' guidelines
Advertise with us - Download our rate card (PDF)
 
Promo graphic: Proud sponsors of the Canadian Abilities Foundation
 
 
 
Landscape of Literacy and Disability (Canadian Abilities Foundation publication) by Ezra Zubrow, et al.

This groundbreaking report definitively shows, using easy-to-read maps, the wide discrepancy of literacy between those with and without disabilities and it provides a critical look at hot-spots across the country. To purchase a copy visit our online store (select Shop online at the top of the homepage).

Landscape of Literacy and Disability
 
 

Your account

With an account at abilities.ca, you can join the conversation, and you can use the website to manage your subscription to the magazine. Signing up is free and easy!




Forgot password? | Create account
 

Email bulletin signup

The Abilities Bulletin is free, monthly, and packed full of news and information you can use.

 

Article Tools

Send a letter to the editor

Share this article through email or social networks